The best MLB cards to invest in

Baseball investment picks ranked by ROI potential

1. Mickey Mantle 1952 Topps

1952 Topps Baseball (1952) · MLB · PSA 10: $4,000,000-$10,000,000+

The most valuable post-war sports card. PSA 10 crossed $12.6M at Heritage in 2022. Lower grades remain six- and seven-figure investments. Permanent grail status.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →

2. Honus Wagner T206

T206 Series (American Tobacco) (1909) · MLB · PSA 10: n/a (none exist)

The most famous sports card in history. Wagner objected to his use in tobacco marketing; the card was pulled from production early. Estimated 50-200 known copies. Has sold above $7M repeatedly; record over $12M.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →

3. Mike Trout 2009 Bowman Chrome Draft Auto

2009 Bowman Chrome Baseball (2009) · MLB · PSA 10: $15,000-$80,000

Modern baseball's GOAT card. PSA 10 Refractor BGS 10 has crossed $4M at auction. Base auto remains the accessible Trout investment tier.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →

4. Roberto Clemente 1955 Topps Rookie

1955 Topps Baseball (1955) · MLB · PSA 10: $1,000,000-$3,000,000

Cultural icon of Latin American baseball. Tragic death legacy plus 3,000 hits plus 12-time All-Star establish permanent demand. PSA 10 pop is extremely low.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →

5. Ken Griffey Jr. 1989 Upper Deck #1

1989 Upper Deck Baseball (1989) · MLB · PSA 10: $2,500-$8,000

Iconic late-junk-wax-era rookie. PSA 10 has rebounded strongly. Set was overprinted but the #1 card has cultural significance.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →

6. Shohei Ohtani 2018 Topps Update

2018 Topps Update Baseball (2018) · MLB · PSA 10: $200-$700

Modern two-way player phenomenon. International collector base supports Japanese-American crossover demand. Multiple parallels exist (Pink, Gold, Black, Refractor) at varying scarcity.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →

7. Ronald Acuña Jr. 2018 Bowman Chrome Auto

2018 Bowman Chrome Baseball (2018) · MLB · PSA 10: $800-$3,500

NL MVP, 40-70 historic season, and franchise face of the Atlanta Braves. Auto rookie established as the modern five-tool MLB rookie investment.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →

8. Juan Soto 2018 Bowman Chrome Auto

2018 Bowman Chrome Baseball (2018) · MLB · PSA 10: $600-$2,500

Generational hitter with elite plate discipline. World Series MVP, multi-year MVP candidate. $765M contract underscores institutional valuation.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →

9. Aaron Judge 2017 Topps Update

2017 Topps Update Baseball (2017) · MLB · PSA 10: $80-$300

62-HR American League record season. Yankees captain, AL MVP. Large-market team plus institutional MLB anchor demand.

Browse on eBay →    Sold comps →    Full review →