Jerry Rice 1986 Topps Rookie vs Barry Sanders 1989 Score Rookie: which is the better sports card investment?

Comparing Jerry Rice 1986 Topps Rookie (1986 Topps Football, 1986) and Barry Sanders 1989 Score Rookie (1989 Score Football, 1989) as sports card investments. PSA price bands, risk, and upside compared.

Jerry Rice 1986 Topps RookieBarry Sanders 1989 Score Rookie
SportNFLNFL
Set1986 Topps Football (1986)1989 Score Football (1989)
RarityStandard rookieStandard rookie
PSA 10 band$3,000-$12,000$2,000-$6,000
PSA 9 band$400-$1,000$200-$500
Raw / ungraded band$80-$250$30-$100
Risk levelLowLow
Investment score5/54/5

Jerry Rice 1986 Topps Rookie

WR GOAT. 3 Super Bowls, all-time receiving records that may never be broken. PSA 10 has appreciated steadily for 20+ years.

Browse Jerry Rice 1986 Topps Rookie on eBay →

View sold comps →

Barry Sanders 1989 Score Rookie

All-time-great RB rookie. Sanders' rushing career and HOF status drive sustained demand. Cleaner-printing card than the 1986 Topps Rice equivalent.

Browse Barry Sanders 1989 Score Rookie on eBay →

View sold comps →

Detailed comparison coming soon.